What’s the worst snub in Emmys history?


Clockwise, from left: Sandra Oh in Killing Eve, Sarah Michelle Gellar in Buffy The Vampire Slayer, BoJack Horseman, and Walton Goggins and Timothy Olyphant in Justified
Graphic: Libby McGuire

The 73rd Primetime Emmy Awards are this Sunday, September 19 at 7: 30 p.m. ET. In honor of the ceremony, we’re taking a peruse support at some of the worst snubs in Emmys history with this week’s AVQ&A:

What’s the most egregious snub in Emmys history?

2 / 10

Michael K. Williams for The Wire

Michael K. Williams for The Wire

There’s a extraordinarily factual likelihood that the slack Michael K. Williams will posthumously capture the Emmy for Eminent Supporting Actor in a Drama on September 19. He imbued his Lovecraft Nation persona, Montrose Freeman, with huge complexity, and the TV Academy is acquainted along with his work, having nominated Williams on four outdated instances—for Bessie, Boardwalk Empire, The Night Of, and When They Survey Us. But by some ability, his most famed characteristic, that of Omar Microscopic on The Wire, escaped the mediate of Emmy voters. Provided that The Wire was itself easiest nominated for two Emmys throughout its complete dawdle, I remark it’s no longer all that suited. But as Omar Microscopic, Williams gave us considered one of the crucial honorable TV characters of all time—opaque at times, nonetheless for the most portion, thrillingly transparent about what he wanted out of lifestyles and how he planned to rating it. The Wire’s lack of Emmy wins is regarded as considered one of the crucial honorable snubs of all time, nonetheless I’d set the oversight of Williams’ work a notch above. [Danette Chavez]

3 / 10

Keri Russell for The Americans

Keri Russell for The Americans

It is some distance a interior most affront to me that Keri Russell (and her pulsing browvein) didn’t capture an Emmy for The Americans despite being nominated 3 times. Her performance as a Russian scrutinize dwelling in Washington D.C. throughout the Chilly Battle was extremely poignant and fierce. She pulled off diversified wigs, outfits, and undercover identities throughout the course of six seasons without letting up on her persona Elizabeth Jennings’ burning intensity and intestine-wrenching emotion. The Emmys no longer awarding Russell her mighty-earned Eminent Lead Actress in a Drama trophy, significantly for the flawless remaining season, is an egregious misstep. On the least it’s a comfort that her co-star and IRL partner Matthew Rhys was identified for season six—and even that was lengthy past due. [Saloni Gajjar]

4 / 10

Sarah Michelle Gellar for Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Sarah Michelle Gellar for Buffy The Vampire Slayer

The truth that Sarah Michelle Gellar didn’t receive a single Emmy nomination for her characteristic as Buffy The Vampire Slayer over the course of seven seasons is solutions boggling. Gellar served as the emotional coronary heart of the sequence, and equipped an empathetic portrayal of a younger, intellectual-eyed woman who will also be an advanced, Mountainous Unhealthy-struggling with slayer. Within the sequence, when she cries, you know your self crying correct along along with her (Buffy’s speech at the cease of “Amends” gets me at any time when). Thru Gellar’s appearing the essence of what a slayer is comes to lifestyles: Sacrificial, resilient, and elephantine of coronary heart. She bodies Buffy’s complexities as a younger hero and woman with grace, even with your complete one-liners. No credit to Joss Whedon is given right here, as the rationale I reach support to gaze BTVS repeatedly again stems from Gellar’s empowering performance as the Chosen One. [Gabrielle Sanchez]

BoJack Horseman

Admittedly: The dawdle of 2014 to 2020—i.e., the BoJack Horseman years—were shapely precise for American difficult TV. On the other hand it aloof hitches in my mind that “Free Churro,” considered one of the crucial productive episodes of my celebrated TV portray of the remaining 10 years, got snubbed in need of a a cramped-above-sensible slack-season Simpsons entry support in 2019. (To grunt nothing of Springfield’s simultaneous overcome the Adventure Time finale, which would contain no lower than felt shimmering as an eventual winner.) BoJack easiest got three nominations throughout its complete dawdle—together with one, for the also criminally-below-Emmy’d Kristen Schaal, for the devastating “That’s Too Worthy, Man!”—which is completely ludicrous in gentle of what a harrowing tightrope it walked for so decades between harrowing emotional honesty and soaring comedy silliness. [William Hughes]


As none of you know, I’m sooner or later getting round to staring at Justified. And as embarrassed as I am for no longer getting right here sooner, the Television Academy might perhaps perhaps aloof be doubly so for ignoring Walton Goggins and Timothy Olyphant proper through the portray’s six seasons. We know they were staring at: both Goggins and Olyphant were nominated in 2011—their first and remaining nominations for Justified. It’s a shame attributable to their gentle-spoken (and on occasion loud-spoken) Kentucky twang made the Elmore Leonard dialogue of Harlan County recount with coronary heart, humor, and humanity. I’m going to double-up on this and suppose Goggins might perhaps perhaps aloof’ve nabbed a nod and a capture for Vice Principals, too, nonetheless it completely’s obvious the Academy’s anti-Goggins stance has rendered the full enterprise suspect. [Matt Schimkowitz]

7 / 10

Steve Carell for The Dwelling of enterprise

Steve Carell for The Dwelling of enterprise

Steve Carell’s stint as underqualified, overconfident regional manager Michael Scott on The Dwelling of enterprise had the be anxious of working alongside the Emmy dominance of three diverse perpetual nominees for Eminent Lead Actor in a Comedy Sequence. When the NBC mockumentary first emerged from the shadow of its U.K. predecessor, Carell’s most sharp Dunder Mifflin work couldn’t traipse past Tony Shalhoub’s endearing embodiment of Adrian Monk; by the time The Dwelling of enterprise was successful with critics and audiences alike, Carell got muscled out by the celebs of an acclaimed community-mate (Alec 1st earl baldwin of bewdley on 30 Rock) and the most traditional portray on TV (Jim Parsons on The Mountainous Bang Theory). He might perhaps perhaps aloof’ve received in 2006, for the season Michael cooked his foot and ruined the Christmas party with Yankee Swap. He might perhaps perhaps’ve received in 2011, as valediction for step by step getting viewers on the aspect of the man who cooked his foot and ruined the Christmas party with Yankee Swap. Aloof, it’s a chunk in-persona that Carell never got the quit prize for having fun with Michael, with the closest he ever came being the year his inclined Day to day Level to colleagues Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert handed him the Eminent Lead Actor in a Comedy Sequence Emmy of absent Dwelling of enterprise co-creator Ricky Gervais—thus marking Gervais’ remaining involvement with one thing silly going down at an awards portray. [Erik Adams]

8 / 10

Lauren Graham for Gilmore Ladies

Lauren Graham for Gilmore Ladies

At this point, Lauren Graham’s lacking Emmy for her performance on Gilmore Ladies is extra the roughly embarrassing “Oops, did we in fact miss that?” error in judgment than anything, nonetheless it completely’s the shortcoming of any nominations in any respect for Eminent Lead Actress in a Comedy (Drama? By which category produce you remark The WB—and later, The CW—set her up for consideration?) throughout the portray’s seven-season dawdle that basically feels a cramped galling, and bigger than a cramped indicative of the biases towards teen- and women folks-centric programming so endemic to the vote casting physique. Whether you’re partial to Amy Sherman-Palladino’s label of speedy-fireplace patter or no longer, it’s laborious to dispute Graham was a damned force of nature on that sequence. [Alex McLevy]

Sandra Oh

I remark my gripe is much less a few particular snub than it is about standard snubbery, nonetheless: How the hell does Sandra Oh no longer contain an Emmy? Oh’s Dr. Cristina Yang was the soul of Grey’s Anatomy throughout your complete first decade of its dawdle—an ride that brought her a diploma of popularity she remembers as nothing lower than traumatic. Nonetheless, she was in stellar work and was identified for five consecutive years in the Eminent Supporting Actress in a Drama Sequence category, nonetheless never took house the trophy. More honest honest as of late, her work as the titular Eve of Killing Eve (which she also executive produces) has brought her support in the Emmys limelight. In 2019, she got four nominations—two for Eve, one for co-web hosting the Golden Globes with Andy Samberg, and one for Eminent Customer Actress in a Comedy for web hosting SNL—and yet she went house empty-handed. That many nods in a year and the Television Academy couldn’t even give her one Emmy? Her vamping overview-stress in the “Cheques” sketch by myself might perhaps perhaps aloof’ve had them tossing awards at her. [Cameron Scheetz]

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.